A refrigerator warranty and a home warranty are two different products that happen to cover the same machine. The refrigerator warranty is the manufacturer's written promise, included in the purchase price, to repair defects in materials or workmanship: one year on the whole refrigerator, five years on the sealed system, and longer on the compressor for some brands. A home warranty is a service contract you buy separately, usually by the year, that covers many home systems and appliances, including the refrigerator, with a service fee for each visit and a cap on what the plan will pay. The manufacturer warranty has no service fee and no cap. The home warranty keeps paying after the manufacturer warranty ends, within its own terms. Claim on the manufacturer warranty first while it applies.
Owners confuse the two warranties because they overlap. Both can pay for a refrigerator repair, both have exclusions, and both ask you to call someone before anyone opens the machine. But they are sold by different people, they cover different things, and they pay in different ways. This guide sets out the difference, side by side, so you can see which one applies to your fault and which one to claim on first.
What a manufacturer warranty is
A manufacturer warranty is the maker's written promise, supplied with the refrigerator and included in the purchase price. It promises to repair or replace the refrigerator when it fails due to a defect in materials or workmanship, under normal household use. The promise lasts one year on the whole refrigerator, five years on the sealed cooling system, and longer on the compressor for some brands. It has no service fee, no claim cap, and no annual payment. It is tied to the refrigerator and to the original purchaser, and it runs from the date of original purchase.
The manufacturer warranty covers defects only. A compressor that fails because it was faulty is covered. A refrigerator dented in a move is not. Food that spoils when the refrigerator stops is not. The maker decides whether the fault is a defect, and the maker's technician diagnoses the cause. The warranty document for your exact model is the authority, and the maker requires proof of purchase to obtain warranty service.
The manufacturer warranty ends. The one-year period ends after a year, the sealed system period ends after five, and the compressor period ends after ten at the latest. When the periods end, the maker pays nothing, whatever the fault. That is when the other warranties begin to matter, because they are the ones that can still pay.
What a home warranty is
A home warranty is a service contract you buy separately, usually by the year, that covers the home's systems and appliances. It is not a warranty in the manufacturer's sense. It is a contract with a home warranty company, and it lists the systems and appliances it covers, including the refrigerator, the oven, the dishwasher, the heating and cooling, and the plumbing and electrical systems. You pay an annual fee for the contract, and a service fee for each visit.
A home warranty covers breakdowns from normal wear and use, which is the opposite of the manufacturer warranty's focus. The manufacturer warranty covers defects that were present when the refrigerator was made. A home warranty covers a refrigerator that breaks down after years of ordinary use, when the manufacturer warranty has long ended. That is its value: it pays for repairs on an older refrigerator, and on older appliances generally, that no manufacturer warranty would still cover.
A home warranty has limits the manufacturer warranty does not. It charges a service fee for each visit, which you pay even when the repair is covered. It caps what it will pay, per claim and sometimes over the life of the contract. It excludes pre-existing faults, and it usually requires a waiting period after the contract starts before a claim can be made. It may repair the refrigerator, or replace it, or pay a cash amount up to the cap, at the company's option. The plan document states the fee, the caps, the waiting period, and the exclusions.
Side by side: what each one pays for
A defect in the first year is the manufacturer warranty's job. The maker pays for parts and labor, with no service fee and no cap. A home warranty would also cover it, in principle, but claiming on the home warranty first would cost you the service fee and use up part of the cap, for a repair the maker would have paid for in full. Claim on the manufacturer warranty first while it applies.
A sealed-system fault inside five years is also the manufacturer warranty's job, with the labor question depending on the brand. LG, Samsung, Whirlpool, KitchenAid, and GE Profile and Cafe pay for parts and labor on the sealed system for five years. Frigidaire covers the sealed-system parts while the owner pays the diagnostic and labor costs. A home warranty may cover the labor Frigidaire does not, within its own terms, which is one case where the two warranties complement each other.
A breakdown from wear after the manufacturer warranty has ended is the home warranty's job. A ten-year-old refrigerator whose compressor fails from age, not from a defect, is outside the manufacturer warranty entirely. A home warranty may pay for the repair, up to its cap, less the service fee. A fault caused by an accident is outside both: the manufacturer warranty excludes accidents, and most home warranty plans exclude them too. Food loss is outside the manufacturer warranty, and some home warranty plans include a food-spoilage allowance with a stated limit, so check the plan document.
Service fees, caps, and waiting periods
The service fee is the home warranty's most important difference. Every visit costs a fee, which you pay whether the repair is large or small. A manufacturer warranty visit costs nothing when the fault is covered. Over several visits, the service fees add up, and a home warranty that charges a fee for each visit can cost more than the repairs it pays for, if the faults are small. Ask what the service fee is before you buy the plan, and ask whether it applies to every visit.
The claim cap is the second difference. A home warranty caps what it will pay, per claim and sometimes over the life of the contract. A sealed-system repair can cost more than a low cap, and the owner pays the difference. A manufacturer warranty has no cap: it pays for the covered repair in full. Ask what the cap is, and whether it applies per claim or over the life of the plan, before you rely on the home warranty for an expensive repair.
The waiting period is the third difference. Most home warranty plans require a waiting period after the contract starts, often 30 days, before a claim can be made. A fault that appears inside the waiting period is not covered, because the plan treats it as pre-existing. A manufacturer warranty has no waiting period: it runs from the date of purchase. If you buy a home warranty because the refrigerator has already started to fail, the waiting period and the pre-existing fault exclusion will usually defeat the claim.
Which one to claim on first
Claim on the manufacturer warranty first while it applies, because it has no service fee and no claim cap. Work out the dates from the purchase date on your invoice: one year for the whole refrigerator, five years for the sealed system, and the compressor period for your brand. If the fault is inside any of those periods, start with the maker. The guide on how to file a refrigerator warranty claim explains the process.
Use the home warranty when the manufacturer warranty has ended, or when the fault is outside the manufacturer warranty but inside the home warranty plan's terms. A breakdown from wear on a refrigerator that is eight years old is a home warranty claim, not a manufacturer claim. A sealed-system repair where the manufacturer covers the part but not the labor, as on Frigidaire models in years two through five, may be a case for claiming the labor through the home warranty plan, if its terms allow it.
Do not claim on both for the same repair without telling each of them. A repair paid for by one plan should not be claimed again from the other, and a repair carried out under one plan's authorization may affect the other's position. Tell each administrator about the other cover, and let them decide how the claim is handled. Keep the paperwork from any repair, because a replacement part fitted under warranty takes on the remaining warranty or 90 days, whichever is longer.
Frequently asked questions
Does a home warranty cover a refrigerator?
Usually yes, within the home warranty plan's own terms. A home warranty is a separate service contract that covers listed home systems and appliances, including the refrigerator, with a service fee per visit and claim caps. It is not the manufacturer's warranty, and its terms decide what it pays for.
What is the difference between a refrigerator warranty and a home warranty?
A refrigerator warranty is the manufacturer's written promise to repair defects in the refrigerator, included in the purchase price, for one year on the whole machine and longer on the sealed system. A home warranty is a service contract you buy separately that covers many home systems and appliances, with a service fee per visit and claim caps.
Does a home warranty cover refrigerator replacement?
It can, within the plan's own terms and caps. Some plans pay for a replacement when the refrigerator cannot be repaired, up to a stated limit, and some pay only for the repair. The plan document states whether replacement is covered and what the cap is.
Which should I claim on first, the manufacturer warranty or the home warranty?
Claim on the manufacturer warranty first while it applies, because it has no service fee and no claim cap. Use the home warranty when the manufacturer warranty has ended, or when the fault is outside the manufacturer warranty but inside the home warranty plan's terms.
Two products, two documents, two claims
This guide is general education about manufacturer warranties and home warranty plans. It is not legal advice, and it does not promise that any particular fault will be covered by either one. The warranty document for your exact model and the home warranty plan document are the authorities. Check both before you rely on anything here, and keep the sales invoice, because the maker requires proof of purchase to obtain warranty service.
Claim on the maker first, while the cover lasts
The manufacturer warranty has no service fee and no cap. The home warranty keeps paying after it ends, within its own terms. Work out the dates, then claim in that order.