It depends on three things: the price of the plan, the cost of the repair it would pay for, and how long you plan to keep the refrigerator. A plan that covers parts and labor on the sealed system after year five can be worth more than one that covers parts only, because a sealed-system repair is mostly labor and refrigerant. A plan that costs a large share of the refrigerator's price, and still excludes the most likely faults, is rarely good value. Read the plan's own terms before deciding, and pay attention to what it covers, when it starts, whether it charges a service fee, and whether it has a claim cap.
An extended warranty is sold at the moment you are least able to judge it: at the checkout, with a new refrigerator already chosen, and a salesperson describing the repair you might one day need. The question is not whether a refrigerator can break. It can. The question is whether the plan you are being offered pays for the repairs that actually happen, at a price that makes sense against the refrigerator you bought. This guide explains the plans, the gaps, and the arithmetic, without recommending any particular plan.
The two kinds of plan
Maker plans are sold by the manufacturer. LG Premium Care, Samsung Care Plus, and Whirlpool Appliance Care are the named plans, and they start after the manufacturer warranty expires. They cover mechanical and electrical failures within their own terms, with the maker's authorized technicians, and they have their own exclusions and limits. LG Premium Care is administered by Asurion, not by LG directly, which is worth knowing, because the administrator is the one who handles the claim.
Retailer plans are sold by the store where the refrigerator was bought. Costco, Home Depot, Lowe's, and Best Buy all sell their own protection plans, and Samsung's own support page names those four retailers when it explains that a claim on a retailer plan goes through the retailer, not through Samsung. Retailer plans are separate service contracts with their own terms, their own service fees, and their own claim caps. The maker does not administer them, and the maker does not decide whether a retailer plan covers a fault.
The two kinds of plan differ in who you call. A maker plan claim goes to the maker or its administrator. A retailer plan claim goes to the retailer. A home warranty plan is a third kind again, and it is covered in the guide on refrigerator warranty versus home warranty. Do not assume that a plan bought from one of them can be claimed on through another. The plan document names the administrator, and that administrator is the one to contact.
When the plan starts, and what that means
Maker plans generally start after the manufacturer warranty expires. That means the first year is covered by the manufacturer warranty, and the plan covers the years after it. Retailer plans vary. Some start at purchase and run alongside the manufacturer warranty, which means the first year is covered twice and the plan's real value starts in year two. Others start when the manufacturer warranty ends. The plan document states the start date, and the start date changes the value: a three-year plan that starts at purchase gives two years of extra cover, while a three-year plan that starts after the manufacturer warranty gives three.
The start date also matters for the sealed system. The manufacturer warranty already covers the sealed system for five years on every major brand, with the labor question depending on the brand. A plan that starts in year two and covers the sealed system adds little in years two through five, because the manufacturer already covers it. Its value starts in year six, when the manufacturer cover narrows to the compressor part only. A plan that covers parts and labor on the sealed system after year five is worth more than one that starts earlier and ends at year five.
Ask the seller when the plan starts, and ask for the answer in writing. If the seller cannot say, read the plan document before you buy. A plan whose start date is not clear is a plan whose value cannot be judged, and that alone is a reason to wait.
The gaps: parts only, service fees, and caps
The most important gap is the same one that appears in the manufacturer warranty: parts-only cover. A plan that covers the compressor part but not the labor to fit it leaves you with the larger share of a sealed-system repair bill. Ask whether the plan covers labor and refrigerant, or parts only. A plan that covers parts and labor on the sealed system is worth more than one that covers parts only, and the difference is the difference between a free repair and a large bill.
The second gap is the service fee. Many plans charge a fee for each visit, which the owner pays even when the repair is covered. A plan with a service fee per visit costs more over several visits than a plan without one, and the fee applies whether the repair is large or small. Ask whether there is a service fee, how much it is, and whether it applies to every visit. The plan document states it, and the seller should too.
The third gap is the claim cap. Some plans cap the total they will pay over the life of the plan, or cap each claim at the purchase price of the refrigerator, or at the cost of a replacement. A cap that is lower than the cost of a sealed-system repair leaves you paying the difference. Ask what the cap is, and whether it applies per claim or over the life of the plan. A plan with a low cap is a plan that may not pay for the repair you bought it for.
The fourth gap is the exclusion list. Plans exclude accidental damage, misuse, improper installation, commercial use, and cosmetic damage, in the same way the manufacturer warranty does. Some plans cover accidental damage as an extra, and some do not. Read the exclusion list in the plan document, and do not rely on what the seller said the plan covers. The document is the authority, and the seller's description is not.
The arithmetic: plan price against repair cost
Weigh the price of the plan against the cost of the repairs it would pay for, and against how long you plan to keep the refrigerator. A low-cost refrigerator that is cheap to replace may cost less to replace than the plan itself, especially if the plan costs a large share of the purchase price. A costly built-in refrigerator, where removal and reinstallation add to the repair bill, is a different calculation, because the repair is expensive and the replacement is more expensive still.
Consider the reliability of the type of refrigerator, and the cost of a typical repair including labor and refrigerant, not just the part. A sealed-system repair is one of the most expensive refrigerator repairs, because it involves refrigerant work and a return visit. A control board or a fan motor is cheaper. A plan that covers the sealed system with parts and labor after year five is worth more on a refrigerator you plan to keep for ten years than on one you plan to replace in five.
Consider how many years you will actually keep the refrigerator. A plan that runs for five years is worth little on a refrigerator you replace in three. A plan that runs for three years is worth little on a refrigerator whose sealed system is already covered by the manufacturer for five. The plan's value is the cover it adds beyond what the manufacturer already gives, for the years you will own the machine.
When a plan is worth considering, and when it is not
A plan is worth considering when the refrigerator is expensive to repair and expensive to replace, when you plan to keep it well beyond the manufacturer warranty, and when the plan covers parts and labor on the sealed system after year five, with a service fee you can accept and a cap above the cost of a sealed-system repair. Those are the conditions, and they are worth checking one by one against the plan document before you buy.
A plan is rarely good value when it costs a large share of the purchase price, when it covers parts only, when it ends before the manufacturer sealed-system cover ends, when the service fee is high, or when the cap is low. It is also rarely good value when the refrigerator is inexpensive to replace, or when you plan to replace it within a few years. In those cases, the money is better kept for the repair or the replacement itself.
There is no deadline for deciding, except the one the seller gives you. A plan can usually be bought after the purchase, within a stated window, and the terms are the same. Do not decide at the checkout under pressure. Take the plan document home, read it, and decide when you have the time to compare it with the manufacturer warranty. The refrigerator warranty guide sets out the manufacturer periods by brand, which is the cover the plan adds to.
Frequently asked questions
Is a refrigerator extended warranty worth it?
It depends on the price of the plan, the cost of a sealed-system repair, and how long you plan to keep the refrigerator. A plan that covers parts and labor on the sealed system after year five can be worth more than one that covers parts only, so read the plan's own terms before deciding.
What does a refrigerator extended warranty cover?
It depends on the plan. Maker plans such as LG Premium Care, Samsung Care Plus, and Whirlpool Appliance Care start after the manufacturer warranty expires and cover mechanical and electrical failures within their own terms. Retailer plans have their own terms, service fees, and claim caps.
When does a refrigerator extended warranty start?
Maker plans generally start after the manufacturer warranty expires. Retailer plans vary: some start at purchase and run alongside the manufacturer warranty, and some start when the manufacturer warranty ends. The plan document states the start date.
Who do I claim on for a retailer refrigerator warranty?
The retailer, not the maker. Samsung's own support page says a claim on an extended warranty bought from a retailer such as Costco, Home Depot, Lowe's, or Best Buy goes through the retailer's website. The maker does not administer retailer plans.
The plan document, not the sales pitch, decides the cover
This guide is general education about refrigerator extended warranties. It is not legal advice, and it does not recommend any particular plan. The plan document is the authority for what a plan covers, when it starts, what service fee applies, and what cap limits it. Read that document before you buy, and keep it with the refrigerator's paperwork.
Take the plan document home before you decide
The start date, the labor question, the service fee, and the cap are the four facts that decide whether a plan is worth it. They are all in the document. Read it first.